The Search for the Best Waterline Eyeliner

Urban Decay’s 24/7 Glide-On Eye Pencil in Perversion. I wanted to love this product. I did. I tried. It’s supposedly loved by many for application to the waterline. The hue is a gorgeous, deep black. The creamy formula is intended for gentle and foolproof application. Now, I don’t know if I have different waterlines than y’all, or if the hype surrounding this liner is mythical, but I could. not. make. it. work. I’ve tried drugstore brands, gel eyeliners, and liquid eyeliners. This and a few other products are supposed to be the holy grail for waterproof, smudgeproof eyeliner. I was excited, but after about a week of trying it, I’m returning it. It’s fine for anywhere BUT the waterline. It budges and shifts within the hour. The formula makes my eyes water. I end up wearing it under my eyes. Honestly, I’ve had better luck with Elf’s gel eyeliner from Target (of all things). Any suggestions? I’m back to square one. Sigh. 
-Anja

Curious? You can check it out here: http://www.urbandecay.com/urban-decay/eye-makeup/24%2F7-glide-on-eye-pencil/122.html